Make these into balls and use them as cockroach bait. Now, here I am giving you all the info I have learned! But borax can do more than clean your house. Like any other pests, cockroaches are drawn to three primary things food, shelter, and water. Its best to keep boric acid away from pets and children. The mixture comes in a bottle, and you can use it straight out of the packet. Many of the commercial insecticide products today contain boric acid as an active ingredient to control cockroaches, termites, fire ants, fleas, silverfish, and other insects. There were 13 major malformations (vs. 7.4 expected), yielding a standardized relative risk ratio (SRR) of 1.75 (95% CI, 0.942.94). and (2) What are the data on the safety of IBA use in pregnancy? Reported toxic or fatal ingestion amounts are also variable. Boric acid is not as strong as some chemicals used for pest control. If a roach died due to boric acid ingestion, and another cockroach eats it, the boric acid will get into the living roach's body. 5 Oz. Studies of birth outcomes in women consuming boron in drinking water are mixed and may be limited by confounders; it is unclear how well these chronic daily exposures throughout pregnancy would relate to the short-term or intermittent exposure resulting from IBA regimens. Boric acid causes the roaches in your home to starve. Different types of roaches like to hide in different locations. The consent submitted will only be used for data processing originating from this website. This is when the baby is developing its neural tube and nervous system. Teratogenic effects of vaginal boric acid treatment during pregnancy Int J Gynaecol Obstet. It's also commonly used in laundry and as a cleaning and deodorizing product. While boric acid has relatively low amounts of toxicity, it can cause minor to severe side effects when consumed and inhaled. Roaches are prolific breeders known to produce several thousand offspring a year. Use a vacuum to clean up the powder to prevent a mess. Despite the name, it is not an acid but a natural compound present in the environment. . You have to be careful with this, though. Please enable scripts and reload this page. 15 minutes (+ drying time) Ingredients 200g of boric acid 1 medium onion (You can use onion flakes but they're not as good) 1 cup of flour 1/4 tsp of salt About 100ml of milk Equipment Metal or ceramic mixing bowl Spoon (not wood or anything porous) Kitchen gloves Directions Finely chop up the onion. It's believed that killing a pregnant cockroach causes the mother to release all of her eggs. Herein, we set out to synthesize human and animal data (converting, where appropriate, dose and serum values to standard units to facilitate comparison) to answer 2 key questions: (1) What are the data on the safety of IBA use for women? I did use boric acid!! The powder will get stuck to their body, and when they ingest it, the boric acid will kill them. Doses of 15 to 20 g in adults are considered potentially lethal; however, studies have not established a clear oral dose limit in mg/kg or measured serum level resulting in either toxicity or death. There are few studies of the impact of IBA use in human pregnancy. Until now that Im pregnant. Finally, use sticky traps to monitor the activity and infestation level in your home. Keep boric acid powder out of direct access or movement of humans and pets. Mosquitoes, especially, prefer folks who are wearing darker clothing such as blue and black. Eliminate and Prevent Roaches Eliminate Pestpit.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com, Amazon.co.uk, and other Amazon stores worldwide. You can buy boric acid from many of the big stores, or you can buy it online at eBay and other similar sites. Boric acid is lethal to insects and is often poison in pesticides. Human data raise some concerns regarding teratogenic effects of IBA; however, it is sparse and flawed. [13] To attract more roaches to the boric acid, mix in 1 part powdered sugar or flour. Using bug spray during pregnancy is risky. While this mix is highly toxic to cockroaches, it is relatively harmless to humans and pets. This method is so highly known that professionals even recommend boric acid powder to kill roaches to their clients. Boric acid is a naturally-occurring compound found in fruits and plants. Did you try the boric acid? The lowest observed adverse effect levelthat is, the lowest dose at which an observed adverse effect level was demonstrated on the fetuseswas 76 mg BA kg1 d1 or 13 mg B kg1 d1. Authorities indicate that it should be used minimally and in conjunction with other measures such as covering up with long sleeves, long pants, socks, covered shoes, and an overall cautious approach. Therefore apply boric acid mildly because if there is a generous amount of it, the roaches will avoid it, and if you inhale it, you may develop respiratory issues. Other pests that are affected by boric acid are mice and ants. Also, women should be counseled to use the medication only intravaginally and to keep it out of reach of children to avoid accidental ingestions. And its easy to make too. - 5 Ways To Kill Or Repel, Where Do Roaches Hide? How Does Boric Acid Kill Roaches? Alternatively in those with true urogenital infections or other pathology, IBA self-treatment may mask disease manifestations, delaying needed medical care or making accurate clinician diagnosis more difficult. Borax is deadly to roaches when consumed. They do this by running feet through their mouth. Few data on the safety of longer-term or suppressive regimens prescribed are available, although significant toxicities have not been reported.3,8,9 Of note, the 600-mg dose of IBA is largely arbitraryno dose-range studies to evaluate safety or efficacy have ever been performed; mechanisms of action are uncertain, although under investigation90s92s; and there are no accepted standardized susceptibility tests for vaginal pathogens such as yeast or trichomonas. a gritty sensation in the vagina. Used properly, though, boric acid is considered safe. Borax has been a household item for a little over a century. Roaches need water. Although low in toxicity, boric acid should be inhaled or ingested due to health concerns. to maintaining your privacy and will not share your personal information without
Summary: Data from one28 and less clearly a second76s human study have raised concerns regarding the teratogenic potential of IBA. In fact, it is one of the things that roaches look for while they scurry around your home. Boric acid is commonly used as a natural insecticide for killing cockroaches and other bugs around the home. With low exposure and occasional use while unlikely to cause a risk to an unborn child in the later stages scientists simply dont have enough information available to them to make a clear indication as to whether or not it can be linked to instances of childhood developmental issues, instances of cancer or other health concerns. When you kill a pregnant cockroach, the eggs will die with it. Boric acid affects the nervous and digestive systems of roaches, eventually leading to their deaths. They carry any number of nasty, horrible infections along with a multitude of different bacteria, as well as cause allergies to flare and asthma to act up. may email you for journal alerts and information, but is committed
Study protocol for a randomized controlled trial. If the roach enters the trap, the boric acid is just another thing that will kill them! When the roach drinks the water, the boric acid is consumed. Dosing pregnant animals with very large amounts of oral BA daily for an extended time can lead to significant fetal problems.67s,68s,80s83s Initial studies by Heindel68s in Sprague-Dawley rats were refined by Price,80s who found no adverse effects seen in the offspring of maternal rats (no-observable-adverse-effect level [NOAEL]) fed 55.1 mg BA kg1 d1 or less from gestational days 0 to 20 (Table 3). Affiliation 1 Second . Im wanting to use boric acid for a couple days just to wipe this thing out entirely but there arent enough studies showing it is entirely safe to use without miscarrying. I was told not to use it while pregnant by midwife. Borax is considered a salt, while boric acid is an inorganic acid. Yes, you can kill roaches with boric acid. These are all common hiding places and areas where you should set traps for roaches. And nothing happened it cleared up my infection and I never got another one! We abstracted data from all available articles regarding use of IBA. Add cup of boric acid and cup of sugar Thus, the major advantage is its effectiveness. Manage Settings Symptoms include fever, headache, weakness, fatigue and painfully swollen lymph nodes. The professional will let you know how long you will need to stay out of your home until the pesticide has completely dissipated. There are a few different options that you can use to treat bug bites while pregnant in a natural way. Summary: Available information suggests low systemic absorption of IBA based on 600 mg suppositories. Apply the boric acid paste to areas of where roaches are sighted or found. I did use boric acid!! You make a mixture with equal parts of sugar and boric acid. is supported by the National Institutes of Health (grant K23AI125715). 3 patients, including those with the lowest and highest blood levels, had GI symptoms; 1 with a blood level of 75.7 g/g WB was asymptomatic, 6001200 mg IBA daily (105210 mg B daily), 0.40 g B/g WB average in those using 6001200 mg IBA, At this level, the main toxicity seen was decrease in fetal birth weight, in addition to some skeletal defects, 6001200 mg IBA daily (105210 mg B intravaginally daily), Absorption expected to be <100%. Boric acid is a product you can buy at just about any general store for under $10. You can also find them in hand soaps, detergents, eyewash, and fertilizers. LOAEL indicates lowest observed adverse effect level (i.e., the lowest dose at which an observed adverse effect level was demonstrated on the fetuses); NOAEL, no-observable-adverse-effect level (i.e., no adverse effects seen in the offspring of maternal rates fed boric acid). You should also avoid inhaling it, as it may cause nausea, headache or vomiting. Those are reasons enough to want to spray these suckers, but here are some more: They will crawl on you at night and expose you to all of the creepy crawly diseases theyve picked up as they scurry through trash, poop and worse. Hope that helps! For baits, cup of boric acid is typically enough to make several bait batches. There are alternatives to using store-bought insecticide products inside the home if you are pregnant. Safety and efficacy of a novel vaginal anti-infective, TOL-463, in the treatment of bacterial vaginosis and vulvovaginal candidiasis: A randomized, single-blind, phase 2, controlled trial. is this stuff safe to put around the house? Fig. I have had the walls of my laundry room open while Remodeling. None of these associations were statistically significant; the authors noted that the association between BA use in the first 4 months and major malformations might merit further investigation. Add sugar to achieve the desired consistency. Intravaginal boric acid (IBA) represents one of the only options available to treat azole-resistant vulvovaginal candidiasis (VVC) and is included as part of multiple national guidelines (including the United Kingdom and the United States) for the treatment of VVC or recurrent bacterial vaginosis. This tool will let you spread the powder with precision. Scatter these trays around your home. Studies show that some populations of cockroaches have learned how to avoid glucose since its typically used in commercial bait. They do report on systemic symptoms resulting from ingestion of 0.2 g/kg BA (14,000 mg in a 70-kg adult).57s A clear limitation of these studies is variable reporting on amount, concentration, and timing of ingestions and when after ingestion blood levels were drawn, as well as patient size (many children included). Boric acid is guaranteed to kill all types and ages of roaches. They are fast, difficult to catch, and will enter your home at will! Data is temporarily unavailable. Table 4, https://links.lww.com/OLQ/A753). I would ask a holistic Dr opinion. Keep boric acid out of common walkways. You can use a duster or pump to treat areas that are difficult to reach, such as inside holes and crevices. In particular, it can cause minor side effects such as irritation, diarrhea, and vomiting in pets. The bug ingests this dust when cleaning itself, which . Instead of Borax, you can use bleach or detergent as a spray to kill cockroaches. Im 8 weeks and struggling bad with bc/yeast. Vulvovaginal candidiasis caused by non-albicans, 24. Borax is usually hauled out from the mineral kernite while boric acid is extracted from the mineral sassolite. This is another way to reduce the swelling. Use boric in the following places to kill roaches: The good thing about boric acid is that it is used to tackle many pests, not just cockroaches! Boric acid to kill cockroaches is a method that can quickly and painlessly rid you of persistent roaches. The cockroaches get attracted to the sugar and eat it along with the boric acid, killing them. When you call, let the service provider know up front that you are pregnant. Manage Settings If you require professional advice, please contact a pest control company. . Boric acid or borax is a naturally-occurring compound found in sea-water, plants, and most fruits. The corrected text should read: The absolute amounts consumed orally in adults or the equivalent in animals associated with adverse effects seem much larger than the individual 600-mg IBA treatments used daily or BID (even if those were to be 100% absorbedIBA may not be), and indeed healthy volunteers who ate or had comparable doses of around 600 mg BA injected IV experienced no ill effects.. Vacuum up any remaining boric acid and clean all the areas where the powder was applied with a wet rag, the next morning. Received for publication April 26, 2021, and accepted September 14, 2021. Nymphs and juveniles usually take less time to die, a maximum of two days. (It is worth noting, however, that boric acid is banned in the UK even for pest control purposes.) Flies, mosquitoes, and other insects carry dangerous, even life threatening diseases and repelling them is far better than being exposed to what they can infect you with. 20. If juvenile roaches are unable to grow into reproductive adults, their population will eventually die. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. This is when the baby is developing its neural tube and nervous system. Remove food sources. Given these factors, it is important to understand the currently available data on the safety of IBA use. I was struggling with the same problem . We were able to identify >1100 individual patient uses based on published literature of IBA use (primarily for VVC).3,710,12,1629,31s53s Most described 600 mg once daily or BID for 7 to 14 days,12,16,2027,29,31s,36s,37s,39s,41s,44s51s whereas others described BID for 1 to 2 months,710,43s,53s or extended or suppressive regimens.3,17,22,23,25,26,29,35s,40s Perhaps the greatest evidence for the safety of IBA is that despite this literature, we were not able to find published reports since the 1880s of serious toxicities. If a cockroach eats or makes contact with boric acid, it'll severely damage its nervous and digestion systems. I have tried 4 different creams and 2 of them burned so bad I had to stop and rinse them out. Formulations vary; commonly, BA powder is placed in a gelatin or vegetable-based capsule for intravaginal use. When the cockroach ingests the boric acid, it starts to dehydrate and dies within 72 hours. Please copy/paste the following text to properly cite this HowStuffWorks.com article: Boric acid is harmful to humans if consumed. You could leave trays of boric acid water in areas where you have noticed roach activity, as they will be drawn to these. Baking soda is a cockroach killer as it is toxic for them. Clin Infect Dis 2015; 61(Suppl. Mittelstaedt, Rachel MD; Kretz, Alyssa BA; Levine, Michael MD; Handa, Victoria L. MD, MHS; Ghanem, Khalil G. MD, PhD; Sobel, Jack D. MD; Powell, Anna MD; Tuddenham, Susan MD, MPH, From the Department of Internal Medicine, Medical School, Johns Hopkins School of Medicine, Baltimore, MD, Department of Emergency Medicine, University of California Los Angeles School of Medicine, Los Angeles, CA, Division of Infectious Disease, Johns Hopkins School of Medicine, Baltimore, MD, Division of Infectious Disease, Wayne State University, Detroit, MI. Boric acid vaginal suppositories: A brief review. They administered 600 mg IBA to 8 uninfected volunteers. In extreme cases, boric acid can lead to kidney failure. Two women treated with IBA at some point in pregnancy had children with skeletal abnormalities, compared with 0 controls (however, authors note they used all population controls, not only matched control pairs for this calculation). There were 5 minor malformations observed versus 4.6 expected (SRR, 1.10 [95% CI, 0.362.53]). Make tiny boric balls with the following ingredients: Mix the ingredients until you get a pie-like consistency. 28 June 2011. ), so use that to your advantage. Boric acid is a natural chemical that can be used to kill cockroaches. Using a pump or duster will also allow you to control how much boric acid you apply on surfaces. Novel products using IBA are under development for treatment and suppression of VVC and bacterial vaginosis. Sexually Transmitted Diseases48(12):e241-e247, December 2021. Call a professional and inform them of your pregnancy. Boric acid is absorbed through the skin and can be harmful if swallowed. Redondo-Lopez V, Lynch M, Schmitt C, et al. Here is a quick bullet point guide. Abstracts were reviewed, reference lists were searched, and relevant articles were abstracted (Suppl. Our findings and analysis are focused on 600 mg IBA regimens commonly described in the literature as prescribed by clinicians. Overall, lack of reported toxicities despite use of IBA for inflammatory conditions such as VVC is reassuring. You can, however, kill baby roaches the minute they hatch by applying boric acid on the ootheca. Peanut butter bait is the best boric recipe. Ingesting large amounts of boric acid can be fatal. There are natural ways that can deter roaches, such as tea tree oilor mothballs. National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (NIAID). Has anyone had experience with boric acid while pregnant? If possible, baiting should be done outside the home as well. Boric acid is toxic to cockroaches and several other common household pests. While not as potent as commercial roach baits, Boric Acid has been proven to be fairly effective against troublesome insects like termites and ants, a lot of homeowners are using the boric acid roach killer to rid their homes of roaches. Here are some of the simple ways in which you can use this compound to get rid of roaches: The most direct way is to spray the boric acid in areas where roaches usually roam. Is boric acid harmful to humans? Boric acid is a naturally occurring compound with antifungal and antimicrobial properties. She reassured me that its safe to use during pregnancy after I mentioned all the warnings I found on the internet not to use boric acid while pregnant. Available at: 16. Shake the Harris Boric Acid Roach Powder with Lure well before opening. Is It Safe To Spray For Roaches While Pregnant? document.getElementById("ak_js_1").setAttribute("value",(new Date()).getTime()); The articles on Pestpit.com are informational only and are regarding DIY pest control. These things are natural ways to repel bugs that are in no way harmful to a pregnant woman. Among 20 participants, none had detectable serum BA levels after 14 days of IBA. It can only work if a cockroach crawls through it and has the powder all over its legs and body. You need to wear long sleeves and no shorts. Intravaginal boric acid (IBA) has been used for decades to treat vulvovaginal candidiasis (VVC) and bacterial vaginosis (BV).13 Intravaginal boric acid represents one of the few available options for azole-resistant Candida,46 is a treatment of last resort for nitroimidazole-resistant trichomoniasis (TV; 4%10% of TV isolates show some nitroimidazole resistance6,7),5,810 and is included as part of multiple national guidelines (Table 1) for infectious vaginitis. Yes, topical boric acid suppositories are safe to use during pregnancy. BASIC study: Is intravaginal boric acid non-inferior to metronidazole in symptomatic bacterial vaginosis? Boric acid should not be used during pregnancy it's toxic to the developing fetus. For more information on how to treat typical household roaches, read these articles: Mixing Borax with food is one of the best ways you can do it for roaches. I also recommend a duster to apply the right amount into small crevices and hard to reach places. Some minor side-effects of boric acid on humans are skin and eye irritation. When applying boric acid, remember to use a face mask and gloves for safety. That is, roaches spread Boric Acid to other cockroaches. However, data are limited, primarily to 8 uninfected volunteers, with an estimate of 6% absorption based on data from a single individual.44s Long clinical experience (in the context of VVC, where inflammation might be expected) would suggest little danger of toxicity at least when 600 mg IBA is used daily or BID; however, the exact amount of systemic absorption in women with inflamed vaginal mucosa or mucosal ulceration is uncertain. Any signs of droppings or discarded skin are a good thing. But since peanut butter is made primarily of protein, they remain to be an effective bait. A full review of all case reports of oral toxicity is outside of the scope of this article (see Hadrup et al.65s for additional details). Risk factors for recurrent vulvovaginal candidiasis in women receiving maintenance antifungal therapy: Results of a prospective cohort study. What are the side effects of boric acid suppositories? Boric acid causes irritation to open wounds in and around the vagina and should not be used in such cases. Boric Acid Suppositories How To Use. How long does it take for boric acid to kill roaches? Supplemental digital content is available for this article. 1. Because cockroaches aren't picky when it comes to food, they will often eat dead roaches. It should only be used as a vaginal suppository when prescribed by a health care provider. * Clinicians' use of intravaginal boric acid maintenance therapy for recurrent vulvovaginal candidiasis and bacterial vaginosis. Both work much faster and better than boric acid. Clean the sink, oven and all cabinets, drawers and countertops with water and a mild detergent. If you store stacks of cardboard, or paper or have too much furniture, your house will be an apt place for them to build a nest. In pregnant women they can cause respiratory issues. It will clear up on its own within a day or two time. Of note, the amount of BA used daily in these cases would appear to be substantially larger (25100 times) than the 600 mg daily or BID commonly prescribed or advised in guidelines. Here, a pregnant German cockroach carries her purse-shaped, light brown egg case, called an ootheca. But keep in mind that boric acid doesn't kill them instantly like other chemical pesticides and insecticides. Boric acid for recurrent vulvovaginal candidiasis: The clinical evidence. Use baits. Marrazzo JM, Dombrowski JC, Wierzbicki MR, et al. Unintended Pregnancy in the United States [Internet]. Boric acid for roaches is a go-to method of killing roaches that your grandmother and mother likely used. Remember to switch up your bait every few weeks. Water sources should be eliminated by caulking cracks around faucets and pipe fittings. Every insecticide is poisonous to some extent, with research suggesting that when given in higher doses of exposure, it can possibly be a contributing factor towards miscarriages, as well as preterm deliveries or even birth defects. Prior to them coming, remove all of your food, dishes, and utensils from your home. This is so when they come to get rid of the infestation theyll take the necessary steps to be especially careful when applying any chemicals. Boric acid is commonly used as a natural insecticide for killing cockroaches and other bugs around the home. 20 Mule Team Borax is very effective in controlling a wide . High-level oral exposure to BA in animals is teratogenic. 3. Boric acid is pretty effective at killing roaches but is not a fast instantaneous solution. There are also some things around your home (apart from your shoes) that can kill cockroaches, such as bleach. About 3 months after he moved in, I saw a cockroach running across my kitchen floor. Can You Use Tea Tree Oil To Deter Roaches? My baby is perfectly healthy smiling, and was right on her due date with no issues! You can use it for ants, bed bugs, and even silverfish. We and our partners use data for Personalised ads and content, ad and content measurement, audience insights and product development. I'm so nervous about getting a pest company to come out and treat, but the thought of letting the roaches get out of control (which I guess they already are) is just as bad. If you are going to make up a spray, use 1/2 cup of boric acid, and 1 pint of water. Get Rid Of German Roaches FOR GOOD - Using Boric Acid - Worst Roach Infestation. Apply a sticky trap to have a good look at exactly what youre dealing with. If you want to stop roaches from populating, I recommend using IGRs. How long does it take boric acid to kill roaches? Wear clothing that is loose fitting. Sobel JD, Vazquez JA. For medium or large infestations, it will take much longer. If a roach ingests boric acid, it will usually die within 72 hours. The water should contain boric acid. and S.T. They thrive in dark and damp places, and their favorite in-home living and breeding grounds are under sinks and refrigerators. When you get back home, open all windows possible in order to air the entire house. As mentioned, roaches are not attracted to Borax. Also, if you are a good shot, you should be targeting direct hits on a roach! Special Offer on Antivirus Software From HowStuffWorks and TotalAV Security. 17. I live in a townhouse and a new neighbor moved in next door. So I am battling with the creams and the Diflucan pill is just garbage none of this stuff helps AT ALL. Studies show that at 2 grams per meter squared, roaches have a 30% mortality rate within 24 hours and a mortality rate of 100% after 15 days. numb_princess16 27 days ago. 29. You only need to spread very thin film and one tap on the shaker should do. 5 Ways Using Boric Acid To Kill Roaches, Using Boric Acid To Kill Cockroaches - 5 Ways, 11 Scents You Should Consider Using To Repel Roaches, Does Bleach Kill Cockroaches? Clean behind and under the refrigerator. While boric acid has a higher toxicity level than Demacrous Earth, both have relatively low amounts. Boric acid is a weak acid (pKa = 9.15), existing in aqueous solutions at or below pH 7 as undissociated boric acid. J.D.S. While grooming itself, the pest then ingests this dust, which attacks its nervous system. However, there is a high likelihood that the insects that were in contact with boric acid will bring it also to the vicinity of the eggs. Is Boric Acid Dangerous to Humans? Since then, I've tested pest control techniques to see what works and what doesn't. All you need to do is mix one teaspoon of peanut butter for every two tablespoons of Borax. Make sure you handle it with care when applying. Kennedy MA, Sobel JD. Symptomatic vulvovaginitis due to fluconazole-resistant, 26. 12. Subsequent studies reported fetal skeletal abnormalities, decreased weight, and visceral abnormalities when pregnant animals were given large amounts of BA.81s83s The Code of Federal Regulations (21 CFR 170.22) for food additive procedural regulations typically necessitates a safety factor of 100 be applied to the NOAEL from animal data before extrapolating to the human data for determining a tolerable daily intake (TDI) in humans.84s The US Environmental Protection Agency has established an oral reference dose of 0.2mg B kg1 d1, as a dose that is presumed to pose no risk of adverse effects during a lifetime of exposure.85s The World Health Organization has established a TDI of 0.17 mg B/kg.86s,87s. When using boric acid, using a mask and gloves are sufficient to protect you. However, it's important to know about its risks if you are pregnant or may want children sometime soon because this chemical has been linked with serious health problems during pregnancy including miscarriage and birth defects among others! You'll find the boric acid in grocery and hardware stores. In another study, 562 to 611 mg BA was administered to human males intravenously (IV) for 20 minutes.64s No volunteer in either study experienced ill effects. Notes on Boric Acid and Cockroaches Needs Some Expertise Using boric acid on cockroaches can work, but correct application is key. For best results, you want to apply just enough that the powder is barely visible. These women exhibited formication, depression, corrosion of vaginal mucous membrane, sunken eyes, weak voice, and skin swelling, charring, and skin exfoliation, which resolved on stopping the therapy, and were ascribed to BA toxicity. The owner of this website does not guarantee offers on this site and all offers should be viewed as recommendations only.